© 2026 WGLT
A public service of Illinois State University
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations
A WGLT series takes a closer look at the allegations Country has made against the American Farm Bureau, including state and national implications.

Critics fear Farm Bureau-backed One Big Beautiful Bill broke a coalition that's not easy to fix

Some five million people nationwide have already lost federal food benefits since the passage of the One Big Beautiful Bill.
LM Otero
/
AP
Some five million people nationwide have already lost federal food benefits since the passage of the One Big Beautiful Bill.

When Congress cut about $186 billion over the next decade from the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program as part of the so-called One Big Beautiful Bill last year, it reallocated about $60 billion in new “farm safety net” money for things like farm payments and crop insurance.

That won praise from the American Farm Bureau Federation, or AFBF.

"Farmers and ranchers are the foundation of America’s food supply chain, and they need the certainty that this legislation will provide,” the group said in a release quoted by the Republican-led Senate Finance Committee. The massive tax and spending bill passed along party lines.

Farm policy expert Jonathan Coppess said moving funding from the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP, to farmers broke a longstanding coalition between "food assistance interests and other sort of cross-partisan rural/urban coalitions."

"That had always been the cardinal political rule, that to hold the coalition together, you couldn't do that," said Coppess, an associate professor of agriculture policy at the University of Illinois.

Behind this decision, the American Farm Bureau’s immense lobbying power and influence loomed, as documented by scientists and attorneys. And despite calling itself the “Voice of Agriculture,” not all farmers feel the AFBF speaks for them.

Karen Perry Stillerman is the deputy director of the food and environment program for the Union of Concerned Scientists, or UCS, and a co-author of the 2024 report Cultivating Control: Corporate Lobbying on the Food and Farm Bill.
Courtesy
/
Stillerman
Karen Perry Stillerman is the deputy director of the food and environment program for the Union of Concerned Scientists, or UCS, and a co-author of the 2024 report Cultivating Control: Corporate Lobbying on the Food and Farm Bill.

'Cultivating Control'

The One Big Beautiful Bill was hardly the AFBF’s first time helping to shape sweeping legislation impacting millions of Americans. It does so every few years with the Farm Bill.

Karen Perry Stillerman is the deputy director of the food and environment program for the Union of Concerned Scientists, or UCS, and a co-author of the 2024 report Cultivating Control: Corporate Lobbying on the Food and Farm Bill. Stillerman said the UCS studies and makes recommendations “mostly for federal policies that can make our food system and our agriculture system more sustainable, healthy and fair."

Cultivating Control reveals “giant agribusiness companies and industry associations spent well over half a billion dollars lobbying Congress to influence legislation that includes the next food and farm bill.”

That exceeds lobbying from the defense industry as well as the combined oil and gas industry.

The UCS report also includes a case study about AFBF and addresses its habit of counting “millions of non-farmer customers of its state-based insurance businesses as members.” That practice is at the center of a lawsuit that Bloomington-based Country Financial has filed against AFBF. The AFBF and associated state farm bureaus are together one of the top contributors to Farm Bill lobbying — nearly $16 million over a four-year period, according to the UCS report.

When WGLT asked Stillerman about the Country lawsuit, she said, “I'm not surprised by this dispute.”

“It shines a light on what seems like a pretty unmistakable truth about the American Farm Bureau Federation, and that's that the organization really isn't fundamentally first and foremost about representing the interests of farmers,” Stillerman said.

She said while the AFBF “purports to represent farmers,” they “actively act against the best interest of that constituency.”

AFBF disputes that characterization and shared this statement with WGLT:

“Farm Bureau is a grassroots organization formed by farmers, for farmers, led by farmers in all 50 states and Puerto Rico. National Farm Bureau policy is developed from the ground up, starting at the county level, through state Farm Bureaus and finalized at our national convention by more than 350 farmer delegates chosen by their state Farm Bureaus. In 2026, 98% of our delegates were family farmers and more than two-thirds operate small- to mid-size farms. The policies they establish direct AFBF’s advocacy, and AFBF proudly serves at their direction. There are no hidden agendas behind our work despite the best conspiracy theories – just a commitment to serve farmers first.”

The AFBF did not respond to detailed questions for this story. Instead, a spokesperson accused WGLT of a “lack of both transparency and journalistic integrity” for not disclosing that the reporter of this three-part series previously worked at Country Financial. [The reporter last worked at Country four years ago and left voluntarily.] After the first story in the series was published Monday, AFBF Vice President for Communications Terri Moore requested WGLT not publish the remaining stories and said AFBF’s lawyers were reviewing the first story for potentially defamatory statements.

In its response to Country’s lawsuit, AFBF previously said its state-level memberships have “translated into larger state dues paid to AFBF to fund programming and advocacy for the benefit of all U.S. farmers and ranchers.”

The 'voice of agriculture' doesn’t speak for all farmers

The American Farm Bureau refers to itself as the Voice of Agriculture, but not all farmers agree this is true – especially when it comes to how they are represented in Washington.

Shelby Watson-Hampton said the Farm Bureau has "anointed themselves ‘the voice of [American] agriculture,’ and even farmers who might not agree with all of their policies don’t want to be left behind with no voice at all."

Watson-Hampton is a farmer, agricultural journalist and longtime member of the Maryland Farm Bureau. Watson-Hampton said farmers don’t come in one political size and shape.

"While it’s a common stereotype that the agricultural community is made up entirely of right-wing individuals, folks in rural areas aren't a political monolith,” Watson-Hampton said. “Plenty of independent and left-leaning farmers and ranchers sit inside the Farm Bureau as well."

Shelby Watson-Hampton is a farmer, agricultural journalist and longtime member of the Maryland Farm Bureau
Courtesy
/
Shelby Watson-Hampton
Shelby Watson-Hampton is a farmer, agricultural journalist and longtime member of the Maryland Farm Bureau.

When WGLT asked the Illinois Farm Bureau if the AFBF's lobbying represents the issues of most farmers, and specifically Midwestern, Illinois and McLean County farmers, it responded: “IFB will always advocate for Illinois agriculture at the local, state and federal levels, based on the priorities important to our members.”

Country Financial declined to comment for this story.

Stillerman cited the AFBF's stance on climate change as one example. She said climate change is "an existential issue for farmers who are facing increasing flooding, drought, pests and other challenges due to climate change."

Yet when she searched the AFBF's website for "climate change," the first article that returned was a policy stance from 2018 which effectively questioned the legitimacy of climate change. It says “Farm Bureau recognizes there may be an increase in occurrences of extreme weather. It is not clear if this is due to natural global climate cycles or other factors, such as [greenhouse gases].”

In 2020, NPR covered some shifts by the AFBF toward supporting certain kinds of climate change legislation, but this information is harder to find on the AFBF’s website. The AFBF did not respond to WGLT’s request for its current stance on climate change.

Stillerman said she doesn't think the AFBF is still “actively denying the science and approaching the issue of climate change the same way today,” referring to the AFBF’s shift from its historical stance of opposing federal climate and cap-and-trade regulations to supporting voluntary approaches for carbon sequestration and emission reductions. But the AFBF continues to downplay an issue that farmers need real action on, quickly, Stillerman said.

Regarding the political makeup of farmers nationwide that the AFBF purports to represent, Watson-Hampton said bipartisan advocacy is the way to go.

"I know members who wish for the opportunity to have truly bipartisan advocacy untethered from party ideologies that better reflects the complicated, diverse and changing landscape that modern U.S. agriculture is,” she told WGLT. “Some of these farmers also remain active members of the organization because they hope to nurture positive changes from within."

Pushing back on regulations

The Union of Concerned Scientists report also accused the AFBF of spreading "disinformation to stoke fears of rampant regulations hurting family farms" and "disinformation-fueled lobbying." These accusations echo Country's allegations that AFBF "made inaccurate and misleading statements about [Country] to its policyholders and the public for the purpose of discrediting” Country.

"Making the Clean Water Act a boogeyman, making climate action a boogeyman, is disinformation. And it's not helpful to the very people that they claim to serve," Stillerman said.

The AFBF did not respond to WGLT’s request for comment on the UCS report.

Carrie La Seur is a Rhodes Scholar and graduate of Yale Law School who works full-time in law and nonprofit management. She published an article for Ecology Law Quarterly in September entitled The Rise of Anti-Regulatory Legal Advocacy: The Farm Bureau Case Study.

La Seur’s article begins, “While the public perceives the American Farm Bureau Federation and its state affiliates as innocuous insurance providers and traditional advocates for the family farmer, they are in fact responsible for a wide-ranging, corporatist siege on the U.S. regulatory state. This article reveals the true nature of Farm Bureau’s unique hybrid structure — a 501(c)(5) nonprofit network fronting for multi-billion dollar insurance and agribusiness interests and a wider web of corporate dark money.”

La Seur’s report alleges that between 2020 and 2025, the AFBF deployed its legal resources to dismantle federal and state oversight, challenge environmental standards and oppose labor and immigration policies impacting agricultural workers. The report analyses the AFBF’s practice of boosting membership numbers with non-farming insurance customers and claims those premium dollars are invested in corporate giants like ConAgra, Tyson and Bayer.

The report also addressed the connection to Country’s lawsuit: “Although this is an insurance business-related claim, it is relevant to AFBF’s tight control of affiliates and desire to require Farm Bureau membership of all insurance policyholders — an essential component of its large membership claims and lobbying power.”

La Seur’s article is the basis of a planned 2028 book from The New Press.

Farm Bill and SNAP’s future

The Farm Bill is a massive multiyear law that governs an array of agricultural and food programs. It is traditionally enacted every five or six years. The last Farm Bill was enacted in 2018 for five years, with temporary extensions since. The One Big Beautiful Bill split the 2018 reauthorization, and most of the programs reauthorized in 2018 have not yet been reauthorized through 2031. The AFBF is pushing for a new five-year Farm Bill by Dec. 31.

Coppess, the University of Illinois professor, described the status of the Farm Bill right now as "unfinished" and said the future of the Farm Bill is "very much unclear" due to the "huge breach" represented by cuts to SNAP. Some five million people nationwide have already lost federal food benefits since the passage of the One Big Beautiful Bill, NPR reported.

"As time goes on, the problems that they created in SNAP are going to make it a lot harder for them to fix these things and reform the coalition," Coppess said.

Grace Hou, Deputy Governor for Health and Human Services at the Office of Governor JB Pritzker, said "We are impatient for the new Congress to address these changes," Hou said. "The changes to the Medicaid program start January 1, so that's just two months away, and we don't think that tax breaks for the wealthy should be on the backs of working individuals who just want health coverage and food on the table. So we're really hoping that there's going to be an about face on H.R. 1, because Illinois communities need that."
Vashon Jordan Jr.
"We are impatient for the new Congress to address these changes," said Grace Hou, Illinois' deputy governor for health and human services.

Grace Hou, Illinois’ deputy governor for health and human services, recently called on the newly-elected Congress to act immediately to restore SNAP funding, among other things. She echoed Coppess' comments about a coalition being broken.

"SNAP has, for its 60-year history, been 100% funded by the federal government, and so they've really kind of, I would say, breached that contract," Hou said in an interview. "When one partner just backs themselves away from the table all of a sudden […] you have chaos and confusion."

Hou also advocated for restoring SNAP funding because of the economic value it brings to Illinois communities.

"For every dollar you invest in SNAP, you're gaining $1.50 to $1.80 for that dollar," she said. Most of the revenue flows through grocery stores, which means "communities, families, as well as businesses are suffering because of these callous decisions," Hou said.

Coppess said by 2031 Congress will have to revisit the Farm Bill, "and it is in that effort that we will see the full extent of the damage to the coalition wrought by the [One Big Beautiful Bill]."

Coppess said it's possible the relationship between the Farm Bill and the SNAP program “can be repaired and rebuilt, or maybe the next Congress fixes the SNAP problems and that helps smooth over the matter." If not, and if "SNAP changes continue and make the situation worse in the States (which makes it more and more expensive to fix) while farm payments continue at record levels and get added to by ad hoc payments, my guess is that it will be increasingly difficult to repair the coalition. Which puts much in jeopardy in a healthy Congress and political environment, more so in what we may still be doing to ourselves politically.”

As for the future of the relationship between Country Financial and the AFBF, both parties head to court Tuesday, Nov. 24.

Jamie Hand is an Economy & Business reporter at WGLT. She joined the station in 2026. You can reach Jamie at jlgrite@ilstu.edu.