Bloomington city leaders appear to be growing impatient with a protracted lawsuit involving a former police sergeant—as another misconduct allegation against one of its co-defendants comes to light.
In new legal filings last week, the city asked a federal judge to reject a request to extend the evidence-gathering period in a yearslong case involving allegations of retaliation within the Bloomington Police Department.
Timmothy Carlton alleges he was fired after raising concerns about what he perceived as an unethical order to racially profile white drivers to balance pull-over demographics among Bloomington Police officers making traffic stops.
The city has denied that allegation, and another in which Carlton says he was unfairly targeted for having spoken out in support of the department’s union members. The city moved to fire Carlton after an internal investigation indicated he’d improperly shared confidential department records with two suspects.
The city has policies in place to protect people who raise concerns about their bosses. City Manager Jeff Jurgens further told WGLT he doesn’t believe retaliation is happening in the police department. But several former and current officers have told WGLT they personally experienced it and don’t trust the police department to fairly judge allegations against high-ranking officers.
‘A pattern and practice’ of retaliation
A motion filed by Carlton’s attorney last month entangled his case with another one recently settled by the City of Bloomington involving the alleged false arrest of two DoorDash drivers in June. The motion suggests a “pattern and practice” of retaliation against BPD officers by former Assistant Police Chief Paul Williams, a defendant in both cases.
Williams and his attorney have not responded to WGLT’s messages asking for comment about either case.
In its response filed in federal court last week, the city rejected any connection between the two cases, noting the June DoorDash incident was related to alleged misconduct against civilians, not officers.
Carlton’s motion says, “a high-ranking officer of BPD has stated there will never be an investigation into Williams’ conduct,” a point it connected to closed-door city council sessions around the time the DoorDash case was filed in August.
“Plaintiff has had almost two years to undertake that investigation and found nothing. He is not entitled to reopen discovery to continue his fishing expedition,” the city's response says, further noting the defendants [the city, Williams, former Assistant Chief Chad Wamsley and Police Chief Jamal Simington] “have been dealing with this matter for years.”
Carlton’s attorney did not respond to WGLT’s request for comment.
WGLT previously reported on Williams’ conduct during his 39-year career with the Bloomington Police Department, including years of disproportionately high overtime and high-volume use of pepper spray while he was a police lieutenant. Officers who worked with him have since alleged abuses of power and an internal police department culture that did not take complaints about Williams’ conduct seriously.
An officer who spoke to WGLT on the condition of anonymity said, “You don’t mess with that guy,” describing the work environment as retaliatory and like “walking on eggshells.”
A former officer said those who made noise about concerning behaviors were either “out or going nowhere,” indicating officers had been held back from promotions if they challenged Williams. Another said they got along with Williams but noted he “did not have a lot of fans.” A third said, “People know Paul is a problem.”
WGLT granted anonymity to the officers because they feared retaliation or were not authorized to speak to the media.
City Manager Jeff Jurgens said the city would look at any allegations of retaliation and pointed to whistleblower protections extended to Bloomington employees, including police officers.
“That’s not the expectation I have for our police department,” he said.
“I do not believe that we have that going on over there,” he said, adding if it was, he’d take steps to address it.
The city’s employee handbook includes a whistleblower policy which clearly states city staff, including its police officers, are protected from retaliation:
“The City of Bloomington will not retaliate against a whistleblower who makes a claim in good faith. Any whistleblower who believes they are being retaliated against must contact the Human Resources Director immediately,” the policy says.
‘She was just upset’
In 2021, one officer did just that. They anonymously reported allegations of gender discrimination in the police department on behalf of another officer.
The letter, which has not previously been reported, alleged a female officer who put in for an assignment in the vice/narcotics unit was told by then-Lt. Paul Williams [who supervised vice at the time] that “she would not be selected because a female would not be able to run her own cases as a narcotics investigator.”
According to the Dec. 2, 2021, letter obtained by WGLT in a Freedom of Information Act request, the officer “felt that this was not directed at her own ability but that it was a general opinion that any female would not be able to conduct narcotics investigations.”
The complaint was referred to BPD’s Office of Professional Standards 12 days later and appears to identify the anonymous officer who made the complaint, according to a department Administrative Investigation Report. The officer’s name is redacted in the report sent to WGLT via a public records request.
That’s despite the anonymous letter stating it was sent to the city's Human Resources department “because the administration in the Police Department has not proven to hold supervisors accountable for wrongful actions in the past.”
The report details an interview with the female officer, who said Williams told her when he worked in vice with other females, “they either weren’t capable of running their own cases, or weren’t allowed to run their own cases, and were historically only used to purchase drugs.”
“She got the impression from those conversations that females are only used to buy drugs and our vice unit does not need that. [Name redacted] said she tried to argue her point, and that she told him that vice is something she’s wanted to do since she got hired, but Lt. Williams then would give several reasons why he thought she shouldn’t do that.”
When asked by then-Assistant Chief Chad Wamsley if she didn’t feel she’d “get a fair shake” in vice, the female officer agreed.
“[B]ased off the conversations she’s had with Lt. Williams,” the report says, the officer, “doesn’t feel she is on even playing ground.”
Three of the seven other officers Wamsley interviewed about the conversation during that investigation corroborated the story. Four said they weren’t aware of any such conversation. Wamsley also interviewed Williams, according to the investigation report, who was asked if there had ever been comments about female officers being turned away from vice.
“Lt. Williams said no,” the report says. “AC Wamsley asked Lt. Williams if he has ever made a comment that females should not be in the vice unit. Lt. Williams said, ‘Well, no, because I don’t believe that…'"
The complaint was dismissed, noting the female officer “advised she was just upset as she felt Lt. Williams was trying to talk her out of putting in for an opening in vice in the future.”
In an interview, Jurgens said he does not know a lot about the 2021 allegation but noted an initiative of Police Chief Jamal Simington to elevate more female officers to leadership positions.
“It’s hard to speak to what has happened in the past,” he said. “What I can speak to is what Chief Simington is trying to accomplish now.”
BPD is participating in the 30x30 initiative, a nationwide effort aimed at boosting the proportion of female officers to 30% by 2030. The effort also advocates that agencies “take measures to increase the representation of women in all ranks of law enforcement."
BPD falls short of the national average, with nine female sworn officers out of 133 total, and a few more are in the hiring pipeline. Three are assigned to specialty roles; two of them are detectives. A department spokesperson declined to say if any women work in vice, since narcotics/street crimes officers may work undercover.
To date, BPD’s highest ranking female officer is retired Sgt. Ivy Thornton, the only woman to reach a supervisory role in the agency. She left in 2025. WGLT has attempted to reach out to Thornton for comment and not heard back.