A first-of-its kind report indicates Illinois lawyers are stressed out. Eleventh Judicial Circuit Chief Judge Mark Fellheimer says that’s not surprising.
“We see folks that may be at the worst point in their life, or the lowest point in their life,” Fellheimer said. “It can be very stressful. And the burden of having someone’s important matter that they’re responsible for can place even more stress upon them.”
The report, released last month by the Illinois Lawyers’ Assistance Program [LAP], indicated one in five Illinois lawyers self-rated their mental health as fair or poor. The survey polled attorneys about the previous year working in law.
“Lawyers and judges see and hear unspeakable things that no human being should have to see or hear,” said Fellheimer, who oversees a circuit that includes McLean County. “You really can’t unsee or unhear those types of things.”
Fellheimer and Circuit Judge Rebecca Foley typically hear cases in the civil division, so they are less likely to encounter graphic material in their courtrooms. But Foley says the work environment isn’t necessarily less stressful.
“A generation ago, mental health was not something that we talked about — and that’s true for the community at large,” she said. “This generation is doing a better job of having these conversations, but we need to continue to work on destigmatizing those conversations to make them more fruitful.”
McLean County talks a lot about mental health. The county, City of Bloomington and Town of Normal contribute to a sales tax fund contributing to mental health initiatives — especially those pertaining to public safety and the criminal justice system. The Criminal Justice Coordinating Council has made mental health a routine talking point. The 11th Judicial Circuit [which encompasses McLean, Ford, Woodford, Livingston and Logan counties] has embraced problem-solving courts aimed at reducing recidivism and getting people help when mental health and substance abuse issues contribute to criminal behavior.
Foley serves as the judicial liaison for the Behavior Health Coordinating Council, the body in charge of developing a countywide behavioral health action plan. She is also a McLean County representative for LAP, which offers confidential support for lawyers and judges who are struggling.
LAP was founded in 1980 in Chicago and has seen an expanding role among lawyers ever since. Initially only dealing with substance abuse problems, it now provides access to mental health counseling and peer support services. The nonprofit added its first downstate office in 2003. The organization’s recent first study on the topic of lawyer mental health, The Weight of Practice, covers stress, depression, substance use, gambling, cognitive acuity and suicidal ideation across a range of work environments [including those working in private, corporate and government settings].
The report found 9% of respondents [5,000 lawyers] drink almost daily, and those who drink frequently also binge drink. Thirty-five percent of lawyers report drinking alcohol both on weekends and during the week. About 70% of those categorized as high-risk drinkers say they have not sought help because they "could handle it on their own." Half say they enjoy drinking and don't want to stop. Younger lawyers report more frequent gambling than older lawyers. The report says 3% of respondents engaged in "problematic gambling," which "is easier to hide than alcohol or drugs and has no physical warning signs."
Fellheimer said stress inevitably comes with the job, but he was surprised with the magnitude of the results — both in the number and severity of mental health concerns. A third the 20% of respondents who rated their mental health “fair” or “poor” have experienced suicidal ideation in the past year, according to the report. That’s about 3,500 lawyers.
In the report, Illinois Supreme Court Justice Mary K. O’Brien said the data on stigma is among the “most dangerous findings in the survey.”
“People don’t come forward when the feel it will be used against them or that it’s such a taboo subject that they feel they can’t talk about it,” O’Brien said.
“We try to act as though this is what we signed up for — and we did,” Fellheimer said. “But I think this report brings out the need to have that conversation, both with the judges and with the bar. I think we sort of put ourselves to the back burner and are more interested in the job in front of us.”
Top sources of stress
Beyond the substance in the courtroom, the survey cites several workplace culture factors as top sources of stress: excessive workload, lack of appreciation, feeling stuck in the job [lack of upward mobility] and unfair compensation.
These were cited as some of the reasons Illinois is implementing sweeping reform to its public defense system. On Jan. 1, Jennifer Soble will oversee indigent defense in Illinois as the state’s first state public defender. Soble, whose appointment was announced Thursday, worked in public defense in Washington, D.C., and Indiana, and most recently was the executive director of the Illinois Prison Project.
Soble’s office is designed to funnel additional resources to counties struggling to staff and finance public defense. The McLean County Public Defender said the county isn’t likely to see much change compared to smaller counties without a full-time public defender, although an Illinois Supreme Court study showed the 11th Judicial Circuit has less than half the attorneys needed to meet demand for public defense. And with no investigators, no social workers and not enough paralegals and support staff throughout the circuit, defendants are left hanging — their attorneys barely able to keep up with caseloads.
Survey respondents in The Weight of Practice are heavily weighted in District 1, covering Chicago and Cook County. Just 12% of participants are from District 4, a massive, 41-county stretch of Northeast and Central Illinois which encompasses the 11th Judicial Circuit and McLean County and contains a fraction of the lawyers.
A dire shortage of downstate attorneys is not part of this study but has been an area of focus for the Illinois Supreme Court. Of the most recent crop of 1,500 new attorneys sworn into the Illinois Bar Association, 63 plan to work in the Fourth District.
Foley said it’s a “reasonable hypothesis” that stress and mental health issues are compounded among lawyers working in or near legal deserts.
“I think it’s reasonable to assume they’re having to stretch themselves even more thinly, which could increase stress,” she said. “There’s no shortage of lawyers in the state of Illinois. Let’s be blunt about that. They’re all up in Chicago. How we can attract people to Central Illinois and the more rural areas remains to be seen.”
Warning signs
Fellheimer said a pattern of missed court dates and deadlines is one way to identify lawyers who might be struggling with their mental health.
“Even though McLean County is larger than most counties in Central Illinois, the judiciary is small enough that if I notice it’s a problem, I may bring it up and say, 'Hey, I’m having an issue in my courtroom. This certain person has dropped the ball. Are you seeing the same thing?'"
LAP is a confidential service available by phone and email to any attorney or judge in the state. Judges and lawyers can contact LAP on their own behalf or on behalf of someone else. Foley, who is sometimes the person making a call to an attorney referred to the program, says that call is met with a mix of responses.
“…on a sliding scale from, maybe a relief that something’s got to change, to much less enthusiastic—more of a denial,” she said.
It is up to that attorney or judge to weigh next steps.
If the concern is grave enough that a judge feels it’s impacting fair representation, they can pull an attorney aside in the moment.
“If you’ve got an attorney who is not showing up to court or who would normally be prepared, and then all of a sudden you see a lack of preparedness, that starts to impact their case, you have to balance that with someone’s right to counsel of their choosing,” she said. “We’ve got some options, but obviously the judge hearing that case doesn’t want to put themselves in that position, because it may look to the parties or the attorneys as a sign of favoritism.”
Fellheimer said the report may raise questions about whether the public should be concerned about its ability to receive effective representation.
“It’s distinguishing to say whether someone’s experiencing stress or a mental health challenge versus someone that is unable to fulfill their professional responsibilities,” he said. “They’re not necessarily the same thing, but lawyers and judges are human beings. Seeking professional help should not be viewed as a weakness. It will allow them to successfully continue to effectively represent their clients.”
Local efforts
Fellheimer said 11th Circuit judges gathered for a session with the Illinois Supreme Court’s Commission on Professionalism, a statewide body aimed at promoting civility in the legal profession. Executive Director Erika Harold, an attorney, former Miss America and advocate against workplace bullying, and a judge from Colorado spoke to the group about vicarious trauma.
The court offers counseling services for jurists when their service concludes, recognizing they too could experience vicarious trauma.
“They have to sit through that, look at autopsy pictures, or graphic pictures, and hear graphic testimony,” Fellheimer said. “We, as a matter of course, when the jury service is over, do offer that to them—which is no different than the lawyers and judges, or our court clerks. It applies to everybody who has to see or hear that kind of stuff.”
Foley said an ongoing question relates to the proliferation of virtual court hearings since 2020, especially in the civil division. As the chief judge during the pandemic, Fellheimer led the courts through the implementation of Zoom hearings. That’s made court more efficient, but it has impacted judges’ ability to catch certain warning signs.
“People can mask a lot of things hiding in their home office as opposed to being in a courtroom,” Foley said. “I worry greatly that a lot of these findings in the survey are not going to come to light for that very reason.”
Lawyers and judges can contact the Lawyers' Assistance Program confidentially on behalf of themselves or another at gethelp@illinoislap.org or by calling (312) 726-6607.
WGLT student reporters Cole Loaicano and Jason Zaehler contributed to this report.