Bloomington’s planning commission recommended the city extend its data center moratorium by a whole year following hours of comments from the public.
A smaller crowd showed for the second hearing on Bloomington’s draft data center regulations Monday night at the Bloomington Center for the Performing Arts with a message generally opposed to the city’s draft regulations, saying an outright ban on hyperscale projects is preferred.
Several of the 29 speakers during the four-plus hour hearing addressed the results of an advisory question on Nov. 3 ballot, asking if voters would support a moratorium on hyperscale data centers. A vast majority, 78%, said yes.
Many who spoke interpreted that to mean support for a permanent moratorium and a sign that voters do not want data centers in town at all.
The commission did not take any binding votes on the regulations but did unanimously pass a resolution encouraging the city to extend its moratorium by 12 months. That resolution will be sent to city council.
The city’s moratorium is set to expire at the end of November. Bloomington staff and council members have previously signaled their intent to extend that moratorium.
PDF: Read the updated draft regulations
Who was there
WGLT observed at least six Bloomington City Council members present at the meeting: Micheal Mosley, Mollie Ward, Abby Scott, John Danenberger, Jenna Kearns and Michael Straza. City Manager Jeff Jurgens, Deputy City Manager Billy Tyus, and Director of Development Services Kelly Pfiefer were also present for all or some of the hearing.
Scott made a Facebook post Monday evening saying she intends to call for extending the moratorium by two years or more, but said regulations are still needed.
“I want the state to come through with their restrictions and requirements,” the post read. “But this doesn’t mean that we can skip the regulations. We need to belt and suspender this.”
Fines still aren’t enough?
Previously the proposed fines for code violations were between $100 and $750 per day. The most recent draft regulations list the following penalties:
- between $150 and $1,000 per code violation per day
- between $300 and $2,000 per use provisions violation per day
- between $450 and $3,000 per performance or operational standard per day
The city could still pursue an administrative suit to enforce compliance or revoke a special use permit for a hyperscale data center.
Several speakers said the fines the city proposed would not be enough, compared to how much money tech giants have.
“Rules that are not enforced are not going to keep anyone safe,” said Ashley Farmer of Bloomington, an Illinois State University criminal justice professor.
“This is not a deterrent model and to be clear, fines rarely are,” Farmer said. “It’s a penny on the sidewalk to most people who wouldn’t even pick up a penny. A fine this small does not discourage a violation. It tells a company that a violation cost practically nothing.”
Commission member John Prior Jr. asked Farmer if a shutdown would be a significant enough punishment. Farmer said she did not believe a company would abide by that and would likely take the city to court to fight that rule.
Noise limits still too noisy
The draft regulations set noise limits from data centers at 57 decibels during the day and 47 decibels at night. Members of the public who spoke were suspicious the noise regulations went far enough.
Ruth Burke, who lives a neighborhood just outside of Bloomington’s city limits, said the proposed sound screens, parapets or other elements meant to erect a physical barrier between the generators and the public would not stop the low, persistent hum of those motors.
“A facility can pass the meter while neighbors lie awake, while I lie awake, while some of your residents… lie awake,” she said.
Burke referenced the World Health Organization’s target for night noise at 40 decibels.
“This draft would allow for more than that, every single night for as long as this facility runs,” she said.
Other speakers shared the same sentiment, saying the low Hertz hum can disrupt sleep.
Burke called for an outright ban. Others suggested distance requirements could protect neighborhoods. How far back generators and chilling devices should go was one of the areas where the commission was given options.
The current draft would require rooftop chilling devices to be at least 500 feet away from homes, hospitals, schools or daycares. Ground chilling devices would need to be 1,000 feet away.
As for generators, rooftop ones would be prohibited, and generators on the ground must be at least 500 feet away from homes, hospitals, schools or daycares.
Staff laid out four options for amending those rules:
- Keeping the regulations as they are
- Restrict rooftop chilling devices and ground-level generators to 1,000 feet away from homes, hospitals, schools or daycares
- Restrict rooftop chilling devices to 1,500 feet
- Restrict all chilling devices and generators to a distance greater than 1,500 feet
As with the prior set of options, city staff laid out its “rationale” and “caveat” for each option. The second and third options align with current data center restrictions in the city of Aurora. For their caveat, city staff said the second option would limit location options, and that the third and fourth options would “effectively ban any hyperscale data center use.”
Energy experts, past data center interest
The commission also called on experts to testify, including Utility Services Vice President for Corn Belt Energy Joe Priestley and Ameren Illinois Economic Development Director Patrick Hoban. An expert witness for water use was not present when called to testify.
Both Hoban and Priestley could not answer specifics on how a large energy user would impact the grid and energy prices, saying it depended on location and other factors.
However, Priestley said any demand of more than 8 megawatts would require significant infrastructure upgrades.
Hoban agreed to that same number during his testimony, and said Ameren asks any large load customer to bear the cost of paying for it, saying it is included in its agreements.
Several members of the public brought up Hoban when referencing a letter submitted to the Bloomington Planning Commission from the last public hearing on Oct. 16, in which a property owner said his family had been approached by data center developers to purchase about 550 acres of their farmland just east of Central Illinois Regional Airport. A neighborhood sits across Ireland Grove from that land.
That letter asked the commission to consider allowing setbacks to be determined on a case-by-case basis, or allow agricultural land to be used for hyperscale data centers instead of select industrial zones. Neither of those recommendations were included in the second draft of the regulations.
Commission member Jackie Beyer asked Hoban for details about the potential energy output of the developer interested in that farmland. Hoban was the CEO for the Bloomington-Normal Economic Development Council from April 2019 through April 2026.
Hoban declined to speak to discussions about data centers that occurred while he was CEO of the Economic Development Council.