© 2026 WGLT
A public service of Illinois State University
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Sarah Duffy appointed to fill retiring judge Costigan's seat

A gavel sits on a judge's bench. On top of that photo, the words "WGLT Courts" appears.
WGLT file photo
A woman in a dark blazer and purple blouse standing in front of a bookshelf filled with law books.
courtesy
/
Fellheimer Law Firm
Sarah Duffy

The Illinois Supreme Court has tabbed Associate Judge Sarah Duffy for a two-month appointment as a circuit judge for the 11th Judicial Circuit, which serves five counties, including McLean.

The judicial shakeup comes as Chief Judge Casey Costigan prepares to retire on Oct. 16.

Judge Mark Fellheimer will return to his prior role as chief judge following Costigan's retirement. The chief judge serves as the administrative head for the courts in McLean, Woodford, Ford, Logan and Livingston counties.

Duffy has served as an associate judge in the 11th Judicial Circuit since 2018. Before that, she was a defense attorney with Fellheimer Law Firm in Pontiac. Duffy earned her undergraduate and law degrees at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.

Circuit judges are appointed when vacancies arise outside of an election cycle. The appointed term ends Dec. 7.

Prior to the appointment, Duffy had announced her run to fill Costigan's seat for a six-year term in the November election. She is running unopposed as a Republican candidate.

Cole Loiacano is a student reporter at WGLT. He joined the station in August 2025.
Lauren Warnecke is the Deputy News Director at WGLT. You can reach Lauren at lewarne@ilstu.edu.