Bloomington Mayor Dan Brady said the city is doing the right thing when it comes to data centers: listening to residents and drafting regulations.
During an interview for WGLT’s Sound Ideas following the planning commission’s second hearing on draft data center regulations, Brady said he wants to see the moratorium time used effectively.
“I think it’s very, very important and relevant that we make sure we have something on the books ordinance-wise,” he said, “that we just don’t take a moratorium and not do something during that timeframe. That we are building a[n], if you will, ordinance structure in which we’ve got answers to the people who come asking about the possibilities of a data center in Bloomington.”
There’s been consistent public sentiment against hyperscale data centers throughout the lifetime of the Bloomington's moratorium on data center projects. Across several hearings or forums this year, including one held jointly with the Town of Normal, residents have spoken at length about their concerns over noise, pollution and energy and water usage associated with data centers.
“There’s people that are very passionate about the issue; I appreciate their passion,” he said. “It’s been exactly what people wanted, which is letting their voice be heard.”
Monday, expert witnesses and community members testified for at least four hours on the city’s second draft of regulations for Bloomington’s Planning Commission.
Those residents criticized the proposed fines in the second draft, saying they aren’t high enough to keep multi-billion-dollar companies in compliance, and said proposed limits on sound and vibration would not protect people from the persistent hum of generators.
Beyond that, those who testified expressed concern over data centers raising their utility rates or jeopardizing the city’s water supply.
Brady suggested the strength of the draft regulations was a matter of opinion.
“That all depends on who you talk to,” Brady said. “What’s strong enough, what’s not strong enough.”
Range of opinions?
Representatives from Corn Belt Energy and Ameren Illinois told the Planning Commission that it is their practice to make customers pay the cost of building the energy infrastructure they need.
Citizens Utility Board Energy Policy Specialist Scott Allen testified Monday he thought the energy provisions were “more than reasonable.”
“They look a lot better than other ordinances I’ve seen around the state,” Allen said.
During Tuesday's interview, Brady suggested the anti-data center comments continually come from the same voices and may not reflect all citizens’ true opinions.
“We have to also be careful that sometimes when you hear from people consistently, it’s the same people,” he said. “Are we getting, I think, a good overall perspective of the view of what people have?”
Voters overwhelmingly supported a moratorium through a nonbinding advisory question on the Nov. 5 ballot. Just under 78% said they would support a moratorium.
Some who spoke Monday night interpreted those results to mean there’s community support for an outright ban. Brady said the city council will do what people are asking for when they likely extend the moratorium at their meeting Nov. 23.
Brady said he supports extending the moratorium to some degree, but demurred from questions asking why the city isn’t pursuing a ban or permanent moratorium in light of that public opinion, saying it’s up to the city council.
“We have other council representatives that maybe have other opinions, so we’re going to listen to those opinions as well,” he said.
Brady said those proposals would not come from him, but someone on the council. He would support a moratorium but did not say he would support a permanent moratorium or ban.
“I don’t know that when you talk about government that anything’s ever permanent,” he said.
Local control
State lawmakers in Springfield could act on proposed data center regulations either during their veto session in late November or during their lame duck session in early January.
Brady was a Republican state representative from 2001 to 2023. He hopes lawmakers leave data center decisions up to municipalities.
“Knowing Springfield like I do,” Brady said, “I hope they leave it to local control and stay out of it.”
“I think we are best suited to come up with something that is personalized if you will to what’s important to the City of Bloomington,” he said. “When things are rushed through Springfield, that’s when you have problems.”